Selly Oak vicar was left fighting for life after doctor missed brain tumour

Sep 9 2010 by Alison Dayani, Birmingham Mail

Although the tumour was benign, extensive surgery and an infection left the active curate, who regularly ran marathons and competed in triathalons, partially disabled in 2005.

“I would call on the Nottingham Trust to take note of how I have suffered and hope it learns lessons so that no-one else has to undergo what my family and I have endured,” said the Rev Underwood, who was studying for a Masters in theology in Nottingham when he became ill.

“I owe my life to the staff at the Birmingham and Midland Eye Centre and the QE Hospital in Birmingham who diagnosed the tumour.

“Without their expertise, dedication, hard work and good humour in the face of extreme difficulties I certainly wouldn’t have made it through this ordeal.”

Solicitor Guy Forster, of legal firm Irwin Mitchell, said: “Despite the fact a brain tumour had been identified, it seems Mr Underwood’s records were subsequently filed and he was not made aware of the growth on his brain.

“As a consequence of the extensive surgery, Mr Underwood unfortunately developed an infection and suffered a seizure which has permanently reduced his mobility.

“He had been an active individual, so this was yet another cruel blow, added to which, his ill health meant he had to retire from his job with the Church.

“Had his tumour been treated in 2001 it is likely he would not have required such drastic surgery and he would have made a full recovery.”

Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust admitted liability and made the out of court settlement this year.

Dr Stephen Fowlie, medical director at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, said: “I wish to reiterate the hospital’s apologies to Mr Underwood and his family for shortcomings in the care he received in 2000.  The delay in diagnosis and treatment of Mr Underwood’s condition should not have occurred. We appreciate the distress and anxiety we have caused Mr Underwood and his family. We hope that the compensation agreed will provide Mr Underwood some security for his future.”